Why Cash for Kidneys is Better than Organ Donation

A kidney transplant is the most performed organ transplant throughout the world. Owing to the challenges that dialysis exposes many individuals with chronic kidney ailments that include reduced life expectancy and low quality of life, but kidney transplantation gives kidney patients the best opportunity to live quality lives with average life expectancy (Becker and Elias, 222-25 ). More importantly, the two ways through which kidney patients can acquire kidneys from donors are cash for the kidney and organ donations. Also, cash for kidneys is used with payment of donors, but Organ donation does not.

To begin with, organ donation is a basic method of exchange owing to the negotiated agreements of the giver and receiver. Kidney donation happens through the willingness of the giver rather than through the influence of the demand and supply. As such, kidney donations fail in meeting the set goals by the shortage of donors. Additionally, the steady surge in delays in getting kidney transplants is firmly connected to significant dependence on kidney donations. Donator s willing to give their kidneys are discouraged by the financial rewards others want to receive by selling their kidneys.

Even the majority of family members of a dead loved one would not sell their members organs for money. (Financial Incentives for Organ Donation, 220-21) Currently, the waiting period for a kidney transplant is usually about four years. As such, people that are scheduled for a kidney transplant, have to wait about four years or so before they can get the treatments necessary. Admittedly, due to the long wait, individuals have to live lives of low quality stretching out the time they have to still deal with the dialysis.

Given that kidney donations happen on informed consent, solving the problem of kidney shortage remains questionable. This information is based on the fact that many individuals who give their permission to donate their kidneys when they die to end up changing their decisions later. For this reason, relying on kidney donations make it hard for planned surgeries to be started on time due to the lack of donated kidneys shall be available at a given time. In turn, due to patients waiting period lengthened, many patients are disappointed that they have to wait even longer. Contrarily, getting cash for kidneys motivates more people to donate a healthy kidney they have, which increases the number of kidneys in supply (Becker and Elias, 222-25). Realistically, paying for kidney does not increase the cost of transplants by significant amounts, and patients guaranteed of getting the transplant started on time since the donors commit to the agreements stated.

Also, cash for kidney s (payment of donors) enable donors to receive proportionate 94financial rewards stopping them from taking advantage of health facilities or individuals who may take advantage of donors by issuing them with minor financial rewards. For clarity, valuation of kidneys is done by relying on factors such as the health risks that donors face after surgery, the reality of noticeable reduction in quality of life, and days spent out of work as donors recover from the procedures. While it is common for organ donators to be exploited, paid donors on the other hand sometimes get deceived owing to desperation to undergo surgery on time. In response, The amounts paid to live donors are limited. As such, some countries have fixed maximum and minimum kidney prices to control these kidney markets accurately by eliminating low payment and lies. Recently, payments to cadaveric donors used to be made after their death. As such, they used not to utilize their compensations. In response to this, quicker payments are encouraged so that even cases whereby relatives would refuse to accomplish the wishes of dead donors can be overturned. Overall, cash for kidneys benefits kidney patients and health systems in general, more than organ donations in exchange for unstandardized incentives.

In conclusion, cash for kidneys is more effective in raising the supply of kidneys to match the demand for kidneys than a donation. organ donation contributes hugely to obtaining kidneys for transplantation. Howeve, a lot of people rely on organ donations by empathetic donors, but the amount of kidneys remains low. Conversely, the establishment of a market for organs allows for fair payment for donors.

Cite this page